The short answer
A REALTOR® builds a comparative market analysis in five steps: define the subject home precisely, select the recent sales most like it in the same community, adjust each sale's price for the ways it differs from the subject, bracket the subject's value between the adjusted comparables, and check the result against the homes currently competing for the same buyers and the months of supply in the segment. The output is a range and a recommended price, with the evidence attached. The method is the same whether the purpose is a listing price or an offer; how a REALTOR® calculates an offer price is the buyer's version. What separates a good analysis from a weak one is the selection and the adjustments, which is why the comparables, not the final number, are the part to ask to see.
Other ways people ask this
People word this question in different ways. This page answers each of them:
- How does a REALTOR® build a comparative market analysis?
- how is a cma done real estate calgary
- What goes into a comparative market analysis for my Calgary home?
- How do real estate agents pick comparable sales and adjust them?
- comparative market analysis calgary how it works
The five steps
| Step | What is done | Where it goes wrong |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Define the subject | Type, style, age, above-grade area by the measurement standard, lot, garage, basement, condition, location details | Using the listing's old square footage or ignoring the basement's status |
| 2. Select comparables | Recent firm sales, same community, same type and style, similar size and age | Leaving the community for a better-looking number; using active listings as sales |
| 3. Adjust | Add or subtract for each difference, from the comparable toward the subject | Adjusting for cost rather than market value; adjusting everything |
| 4. Bracket | Place the subject between adjusted comparables that are slightly better and slightly worse | All comparables on one side; one outlier driving the result |
| 5. Check the market | Competing listings, months of supply, the trend since the comparables sold | Pricing to last spring's comparables in a softer fall |
The rules for how far back and how far out the search can go are in how far back to look at comparable sales, and the hard case, where there is almost nothing to compare, in pricing with no recent comparables.
How adjustments are made
An adjustment is the market's price for a difference, not the cost of creating it. If the comparable has a double garage and the subject a single, the comparable's price is reduced by what buyers in that community pay for the second stall, which is learned from pairs of sales rather than from a builder's quote. The adjustment runs from the comparable toward the subject: a better comparable is adjusted down, a worse one up. Common adjustments in Calgary are above-grade area, developed basement, garage, lot size and position, age and mechanical condition, renovation level, and location details such as a busy road or a green space; the value effects of several are in what makes one home worth more than another. A comparable that needs many large adjustments is a weak comparable, and an honest analysis says so.
How much to trust the result
- Tight bracket, recent sales, same street: high confidence; price inside the range.
- Wide bracket, older sales, adjusted for the trend: moderate; price toward the side the market is moving.
- Comparables from outside the community or far back: low; the price is a hypothesis the first weeks of showings will test.
- Luxury and unusual homes: always lower confidence; why luxury homes take longer.
An appraisal uses the same evidence under a formal method for a lender; the two are compared in appraisal versus market analysis.
What to ask for, and where to start
Ask any REALTOR® who gives you a number for the comparables behind it, the adjustments made, and the months of supply in your segment; an analysis that cannot show those three is an opinion without evidence. Sold prices are not public in Alberta, so the evidence comes through MLS® access: a REALTOR®, or for your own home, Home Beat, which sends you the closest recent sales in your community each month, and the instant home evaluation, which applies your community's actual sales as a starting range. The full analysis, with the judgement a model cannot make, is what a seller call produces.
Quick answers
What is a comparative market analysis?
A REALTOR®'s estimate of what a home would sell for now, built from recent sales of the most similar homes nearby, adjusted for the differences between them and the subject home, and checked against current competing listings and the state of the segment. It is an opinion of value for pricing or offering, not an appraisal for a lender.
How many comparables does a CMA use?
Enough to bracket the home: ideally several recent sales that are a little better and a little worse than it, so the value falls between them. In a thin segment that may mean reaching further back in time or further out in distance, with larger adjustments and less confidence.
Is a CMA the same as an appraisal?
No. An appraisal is prepared by a licensed appraiser for a lender or a legal purpose using a formal method and a fee. A CMA is a REALTOR®'s market opinion for pricing or offering, usually free. They use similar evidence and should land close; when they differ, the comparables chosen are usually the reason.
Can I see the comparables behind a CMA?
Yes, and you should ask. A CMA you cannot see the evidence for is a number, not an analysis. Sold prices are not public in Alberta, which is why a REALTOR® or Home Beat is the route to them.