Red flags

Condo Document Red Flags: What Deserves a Second Look

Every list of condo document red flags has the same problem: read cold, it makes every building look uninsurable.

So start with the rule that governs everything below.

A Red Flag Is a Question, Not a Verdict

A red flag is a reason to ask another question — not necessarily a reason to walk away.

Almost every item on this page has a perfectly reasonable explanation in some buildings. The purpose of noticing one is to find out which building you are in.

Buildings are physical objects that age. Boards make trade-offs. Corporations have disputes. None of that is evidence of a badly run condominium on its own.

What you are trying to establish is whether the corporation knows about its problems, has planned for them, and is dealing with them — or whether it keeps being surprised.

Building and Maintenance Signals

  • Repeated discussion of water intrusion. The one we watch most closely. Water is expensive, often structural, and frequently appears in minutes for years before it appears in a budget.
  • Ongoing building-envelope concerns. Cladding, membranes, balconies and windows are among the costliest categories of work.
  • Major mechanical work — elevator replacement, boilers, HVAC.
  • Parking structure repairs. Parkade remediation is routinely one of the largest single expenses a corporation faces.
  • Roofing or window replacement approaching, particularly where it is not clearly funded.
  • Important issues repeatedly deferred. One deferral is a decision. Repeated deferral of the same item is a pattern.

Financial Signals

  • Very low reserve balances relative to anticipated work. Note the second half of that sentence — the balance alone means nothing. See reserve fund studies.
  • Major work not clearly reflected in reserve planning. Work everyone is discussing that appears in no plan is work nobody is saving for.
  • Repeated special assessments. One assessment can be good management. A pattern of them is a different signal — see special assessments.
  • Significant arrears. Budgeted money that is not being collected.
  • Unexplained financial variances. Particularly a line that overruns every year.
  • Major increases in condo fees. Sometimes a correction by a responsible board; sometimes a symptom. The reason is what matters.

Insurance Signals

  • Large insurance deductibles — because some of that exposure can reach owners. See condo insurance.
  • Recurring insurance claims, especially water claims, which point at an unresolved cause and drive costs for everyone.

Governance Signals

  • Litigation or legal disputes involving the corporation.
  • Repeated management changes. Turnover can mean a board holding managers to account, or a corporation nobody wants to manage.
  • Persistent owner complaints recorded in AGM minutes.

The Pattern Matters More Than Any Single Item

This is the part that separates a useful review from a checklist.

Consider a corporation where the reserve fund study anticipates significant work, the minutes repeatedly discuss the same repair, insurance claims have increased, the budget has little flexibility, and owners are already discussing whether more money will be required.

Any one of those has an explanation. Together they describe a building heading toward a cost that has not yet been named.

Conversely, a building with a completed assessment, a drawn-down reserve and a new roof may set off two items on the list above while being in genuinely good shape.

Read the documents against each other, not one at a time.

What to Do When You Find One

Ask. Then decide.

  • Request further documents or clarification
  • Ask the condominium manager directly
  • Check whether the item appears in the reserve fund planning
  • Read further back in the minutes to see how long it has been running
  • Consider a professional condominium document review
  • Speak with a lawyer where the question is legal
  • Reconsider the price, or the property
  • Or decide the risk is understood and acceptable

What options are actually open to you, and by when, depends on the conditions in your purchase contract. That is a legal question about your specific agreement.

If the Corporation Is in a Lawsuit

Litigation appears in the list above as a single line, and it deserves more than that, because it is the red flag buyers most often either ignore or over-read.

Start with what kind it is. A corporation suing its builder or a trade over defective work is very different from a corporation being sued by an owner, an injured visitor, a contractor it did not pay, or its own insurer. The first may eventually bring money in. The others take money out, and some of them point at how the corporation is run.

What to establish before conditions come off:

  • What the claim is about, and what stage it is at. A filed claim, a claim being defended and a judgment are not the same risk.
  • Who is paying for it. Legal costs show up in the financial statements, sometimes as a line that has grown quietly for years.
  • Whether insurance responds. Some claims are covered, some are not, and the deductible is a cost either way — see condo insurance.
  • What the exposure is if it goes badly, and whether a special assessment has been discussed in connection with it.
  • Whether it has been disclosed on the estoppel certificate, and what the minutes say about it over time.

Then get advice. What a particular proceeding means for you as a prospective owner is a legal question, and it is one of the clearest cases for a lawyer’s opinion during the condition period rather than a view formed from the minutes alone. Lenders and insurers can take their own view of a building in litigation too, so raise it with your broker early.

Is a self-managed condo corporation a red flag?

Not by itself. Many smaller Calgary complexes are run by their own boards without a management company, and some are run very well. What matters is whether the work a manager would normally do is getting done, and the documents show that either way.

What changes without a manager. The board does the bookkeeping, fee collection, insurance renewals, contractor hiring, record keeping and owner notices itself, or hands parts of them to volunteers or paid help. Since December 1, 2021, Alberta has required individuals and companies that provide condominium management services to be licensed by the Real Estate Council of Alberta (RECA). If a self-managed corporation pays someone outside the board for management work, ask whether that person is licensed; RECA’s ProCheck search lists licensees. RECA or a lawyer can confirm whether a particular arrangement needs a licence.

What to check instead of the label:

  • Annual financial statements, reserve fund report and budget, sent to owners at least 14 days before the AGM, as the Condominium Property Act requires.
  • AGMs held on time, no more than 15 months apart, with minutes kept and available.
  • A current reserve fund study and plan, and evidence the board follows it. See the reserve fund study guide.
  • A current insurance certificate and standard insurable unit description.
  • Documents produced on time. A corporation must answer a written request for prescribed documents within 10 days, so a slow or incomplete package is a more useful signal than who sends it.
  • Arrears under control, because collecting from neighbours is harder for a volunteer board.
  • More than one person doing the work. A building that depends on one long-serving volunteer has a succession problem.

A self-managed building with complete, current records can be a sound purchase, and a managed building with missing studies isn’t safer for having a manager. Read the package the same way in both cases, and consider a professional document review where the records are thin.

Found Something in the Documents That Worries You?

Send it to us. We've seen most of it before, and we'll tell you honestly whether it changes the picture.